Return to CreateDebate.comhermus • Join this debate community

Hermus -JRG Grade 7


22hroskom's Waterfall RSS

This personal waterfall shows you all of 22hroskom's arguments, looking across every debate.
0 points

How do you know that it's just the jewish people's land, show me evidence that supports that. Plus the Palestinians have also been living there, longer than the jews

1 point

More than a million in the Gaza Strip, three-quarters of a million in the West Bank, and about a quarter of a million in Israel proper. This shows that the Palestinians need the land they had before, the Palestinians have a bigger population. Plus the Palestinians might have been angry at them for taking the land they had, but they tried to be nice about.

1 point

Neither does the Jews the UN gave the jews some land so that they wouldn't be bullied around. But in the end the jews bullied the palestinians by taking away the land

1 point

I 100% agree with you because the Jews took advantage of the UN, deciding to start wars with everybody so that they would get more land. They are just as bad as the Nazis because they forced people out of their homes.

1 point

Why does that mean that they can take over the whole country knowing that the Palestinians have a big population. They started wars that didnt' need to be started, making different countries lose their land.

4 points

But does that mean that they can forcefully push the Palestinians out of their homes knowing that they have a bigger population. They took the whole country away from the Palestinians, where were the Palestinians supposed to go

1 point

The Jewish people settled and developed the land. As far back as records show, the Jewish people occupied the land.

I don’t disagree with this but I will add something to your statement. The Palestinians have been there the same time as the Israelis have been. Meaning that the Palestinians have had the land longer knowing what could be better for the country. You only think this because most people think that Jerusalem is only for Jewish people.

It is considered a holy city in the three major Abrahamic religions of Judaism, Christianity and Islam.

Jerusalem

5 points

Yes, but did they have to come back forcefully just to get land. They could have shared land that the UN first said. They also took the places that the Palestinians had, the Palestinians need more land too.

1 point

The international community granted the Jewish people the land in 1948. United Nations including the U.S. gave land in Palestine to Israel

Yes they gave you land of the Palestinians but the jews took advantage of the land they were giving. They started war because the Palestinians wanted more land but who can blame them the UN give away most of their land.

At the end of the war, the State of Israel kept the area that had been recommended by the UN General Assembly Resolution 181 as well as almost 60% of the area allocated to the proposed Arab state.

Wars

5 points

I totally agree with you “Palestinians should have their own country as well. Why do the Jews get a homeland on what is our land, and we have not homeland.”

Why would the UN give the Jews there own part of the Palestinians country and since the Jews took over most of it why not give the Palestinians their own land when they have done nothing wrong to anyone.

7 points

Yes they gave you land of the Palestinians but the jews took advantage of the land they were giving. They started war because the Palestinians wanted more land but who can blame them the UN give away most of their land.

2 points

Arab Muslims (Palestinians) have always lived on the land. They never left in great numbers like the Jewish people. There is no time in the history of the area that they have not lived there.

Since Palestinians haven’t left in great numbers for a short period of time why do the Jews get to have most of the land that the Palestinians have. Palestinians have didn’t get a say if the Israelis get to move in the UN just let them in.

Jewish settlements declined from over 160 to 50 by the time of the Muslim conquest. Michael Avi-Yonah calculated that Jews constituted 10–15% of Palestine's population by the time of the Persian invasion of 614,[2]while Moshe Gil claims that Jews constituted the majority of the population until the 7th-century Muslim conquest (638 CE).[3]

Jewish Settlements



Results Per Page: [12] [24] [48] [96]